All cases

Case study · Product Design intensive

A paywall that shows the value before payment

As part of a Product Design intensive, I analysed paywalls in AI language-learning apps and designed my own concept for the Growly app.

Growly paywall concept
Format
Course project
Course
Product Design
Role
UX research · UX/UI
Platform
iOS
Tools
Figma · AppMagic · Meta Ads Library

01 · Overview

The task

The paywall is where users decide to pay or leave. In AI language apps it almost always appears right after onboarding.

The goal: understand how market leaders sell subscriptions, find recurring patterns and use them to design a paywall for Growly, an AI speaking tutor.

  • 5competitor apps
  • 80+onboarding screens reviewed
  • 1key metric: subscription conversion

02 · Research

Five competitors under the microscope

For each app I went through onboarding up to the paywall, pulled stats from AppMagic and reviewed ads in the Meta Ads Library: which promises work and for whom.

  • Learna AI

    Revenue > $5MDownloads > 5M

    Positioning
    AI assistant with a personal learning plan
    Monetisation
    7-day trial → $17.99/week, one plan

    Strength: personalisation — users see their own plan before paying.

  • Speak

    Revenue > $2MDownloads > 500K

    Positioning
    Speak English from day one
    Monetisation
    7-day trial · Premium $119.99/yr · Premium Plus $299.99/yr

    Best plan comparison: a feature table and a Best Value badge.

  • Praktika

    Revenue > $1MDownloads > 1M

    Positioning
    A personal AI tutor, 50× cheaper than a human one
    Monetisation
    7-day trial → $59.99/yr or $9.99/mo

    Explains in detail how the trial works and removes the fear of being charged.

  • Loora

    Revenue > $1MDownloads > 1M

    Positioning
    A personal AI tutor, any time
    Monetisation
    No trial · $119.99/yr (Save 49%) or $19.99/mo

    Strong design and trust (4.9, 500K+ ratings), but no free trial.

  • YayTalk

    Revenue > $200KDownloads > 1M

    Positioning
    AI helper for learning at your own pace
    Monetisation
    3-day trial → $11.99/week · $49.99/yr (−91%)

    Simple and clear: shows right away what the user pays for.

Paywall Learna AI
Learna AI
Paywall Speak
Speak
Paywall Loora
Loora
Paywall YayTalk
YayTalk

03 · Patterns

What everyone repeats

  • 01

    Personal-data survey

    Every app asks about goals, level, interests and daily time — the base for the future “personal plan”.

  • 02

    Plan calculation & reveal

    A “building your plan…” progress screen, then the finished plan — the user sees value before paying.

  • 03

    Social proof

    Ratings, user counts and reviews right before the paywall reduce distrust.

  • 04

    Unusual solutions

    YayTalk’s “promise screen” (press and hold to confirm) and an empathetic survey about the user’s pains.

YayTalk promise screen and personal plan screen
YayTalk: an unusual “promise screen” and the personal plan reveal

04 · Comparison

Side by side

AppTrialSoft paywallBenefitsPersonal planSocial proof“Cancel anytime” CTA
Learna AIyesnonoyesnoyes
Speakyesyesyesnoyesyes
Praktikayesyesyesnoyesyes
Looranoyesnononoyes
YayTalkyesyesyesnonoyes

All paywalls appear after onboarding, and almost all can be closed. Most give 7 free days, explain the benefits and build trust with ratings and user counts. The focus is on the best-value, usually yearly, plan.

Strongest UX: Praktika — it explains value and how the trial works best. Speak wins on plan comparison, Learna on personalisation, YayTalk on simplicity, Loora on design but loses without a trial.

05 · Concept

The Growly paywall

Growly paywall concept
When we show it
After onboarding, once the user has set up their plan and is ready to start.
Why then
They already see the app adapted to their goals and better understand what they pay for.
What value we sell
Not just a subscription, but a personal way to learn English with AI practice and motivation to study daily.
Plans
Year — the best value, with a 7-day trial. 1 Month — a shorter option for those not ready for a year.

Triggers on screen

  • Personalisation — show the personal plan: course, level, focus, 5 min a day
  • Social proof — 4.9/5 rating and 10,000+ happy learners
  • Savings — the yearly plan is marked Best value: $7.50/mo instead of $14.99
  • Transparency — trial timeline: today — access, in 5 days — reminder, in 7 — billing
  • Safety — Secure payment · Cancel anytime under the button

06 · Metrics

How we’ll know it works

Primary metric: subscription conversion — the paywall’s main goal is a purchase.

  • 1“Start free trial” tapsShows whether the paywall sparked interest.
  • 2Paywall dismissalsFrequent closes mean the paywall needs work.
  • 3Plan choiceWhich plan wins — Year or Month.
  • 4Trial startsHow attractive the offer is.

07 · Takeaways

What I took away

An effective paywall must be simple and clear: explain the value of the subscription, show its benefits, build trust and motivate the purchase.
Next focus area Sign-up & onboarding iGaming · FinTech

Need a similar result?

Discuss a project